Related for Rosh Hashanah 63:13
וכשקידשו ב"ד את השנה באושא ירד ר' יוחנן בן ברוקא לפני רשב"ג ועשה כר' יוחנן בן נורי אמר לו רבן שמעון לא היו נוהגין כן ביבנה ליום השני ירד רבי חנינא בנו של רבי יוסי הגלילי ועשה כר"ע אמר רשב"ג כך היו נוהגין ביבנה
Said R'Akiba to him: Why should we not interpret 'a solemn rest' to apply to the abstention from work, seeing that the text placed this first?<span class="x" onmousemove="('comment',' And abstention from work is the first mark of the day.');"><sup>19</sup></span> No; [we should interpret thus]: 'A solemn rest': sanctify it by [abstaining from] the doing of work - 'A memorial': this indicates the remembrance verses.' Proclaimed with the blowing of horns': this indicates shofar-verses.'
Tosefta Rosh Hashanah (Lieberman)
Where it is customary to recite according to the words of R. Akiba, one recites according to the words of R. Akiba. Where it is customary to recite according to the words of R. Johanan ben Nuri, one recites according to the words of R. Johanan ben Nuri. Rabbi says: As we have otherwise found it to be said in the middle, so here it is said in the middle.” When they sanctified the year in Uscha, R. Johanan ben Beroka entered and recited according to the words of R Johanan ben Nuri. Then Rabban Shimbn h Gamli'el said: This was not done in Jabne. On the second day R. Hananiah, the son of R Jose ha-glili, stepped forward and said R Akiba accordingly. So said R Shimbn b Garmli'el Thus was it done in Jabne.
Ask RabbiBookmarkShareCopy